ul ol indentation

I have tried every bit of css I know to try in order to get the second and subsequent lines of a bullet or numbered list item to indent, but cannot figure it out. The text in those lines needs to line up with the text in the first line. I’ve attached a screen shot of how an ordered list renders (without any custom css), but it’s the same with bullet (ul) lists too. It renders the same in IE, FF, and Chrome, and occurs in both Pages and Posts, and I’d like to solve it in both places. I’m sure I’m just missing a simple selector somehow, but must finally turn to you all for help. If you could just give me the code and tell me where to save it, I’ll be much obliged